Peer Review Process

Dharma Raflesia: Jurnal Ilmiah Pengembangan dan Penerapan IPTEKS applies a pre-review and peer review process. Each submission of the manuscript will be reviewed by independent reviewers, followed by editorial comments. Editor-in-Chief or editor, in accordance with the field of the manuscript, will provide a decision of acceptance/rejection.

Pre-review manuscript

Every submitted manuscript will undergo an initial assessment/pre-review assessment to determine whether the manuscript is in line with the journal's scope and follows the journal template. Manuscripts that do not comply with the journal’s focus and scope, guidelines, and submission requirements will be rejected. Manuscripts that pass the pre-review stage will be forwarded to reviewers for peer-reviewed process.

Blind peer-reviewed

Every manuscript that passes the pre-review stage will undergo a double-blind peer review process. The identities of both authors and reviewers will remain anonymous. The entire process is managed by the Editorial Board. There is no direct communication between authors and reviewers.

Editor Decision 

The Editorial Board makes the final publication decision by carefully considering the reviewers’ evaluations. The manuscript evaluation process generally takes approximately 2-3 months. The possible editorial decisions are: reject, major revision, minor revision, or accept.