Main Article Content

Abstract

Meta-analysis study of the effect of transportation distance on physiological conditions, pre-slaughter and broiler meat quality was carried out to examine the magnitude of the effect and calculate the publication bias of the effect of transportation distance on physiological conditions, pre-slaughter and broiler meat quality. The materials obtained from 1123 studies and 622 relevant studies were selected from 62 journals for further analysis. Parameters observed related to physiological conditions consisted of blood glucose levels, corticosterone levels, and body temperature. Parameters of pre-slaughter conditions on arrival were observed from weight loss and mortality. Meat quality parameters were observed from the percentage of drip loss, pH, and meat color. Transportation distances are categorized into various moderator individual and combined distances, namely <60 km, 60-180 km, >180 km and combined distances (a collection of distances <60 km, 60-180 km, and >180 km). The data obtained were tabulated and analyzed using CMA 3.7 software. The results showed a negative effect of transportation distances on physiological conditions, pre-slaughter and broiler meat quality with a moderate level of determination (est. 0.3-0.5) to strong on the parameters of physiological conditions, pre-slaughter and broiler meat quality. (est. 0.5-1.0). Publication bias was found in several parameters such as corticosterone levels and color (redness) did not show a significant egger's test result (p>0.05), which are potentially having an interfere with the interpretation of the study results. However the significant results of the Rosenthal analysis (p<0.05)) means that the intervention did not change the overall interpretation of the data. It concluded that transportation distance had a negative effect on physiological conditions, pre-slaughter and broiler meat quality with a moderate to strong effect and the consistency of publication results.


 

Keywords

Meta-analysis broiler glucose corticosterone body temperature weight loss mortality drip loss pH yellowness redness lightness transportation distance

Article Details

How to Cite
Sarjana, T. A., Adiwangsa, R. P., & Muryani, R. (2022). Meta-Analysis: Effect of Transport Distance on Physiological Conditions, Pre-Slaughter, and Broiler Meat Quality. Jurnal Sain Peternakan Indonesia, 17(4), 238–250. https://doi.org/10.31186/jspi.id.17.4.238-250

References

  1. A.H. Al-obaidy, A. Q. Shanoon, and D. H. Al-Hassani. 2020. Evaluation of the stress of transporting broiler chickens in iraq on some productive, physiological and economic characteristics. Iraqi Journal of Agricultural Sciences 51:752–759.
  2. Al-Abdullatif, A. A., A. A. Al-Sagan, E. O. S. Hussein, I. M. Saadeldin, G. M. Suliman, M. M. Azzam, S. I. Al-Mufarrej, and R. A. Alhotan. 2021. Betaine could help ameliorate transport associated water deprivation stress in broilers by reducing the expression of stress-related transcripts and modulating water channel activity. Ital J Anim Sci 20:14–25.
  3. Benincasa, N. C., K. S. Sakamoto, I. J. O. Silva, and C. M. V. Lobos. 2020. Animal welfare: impacts of pre-slaughter operations on the current poultry industry. Journal of Animal Behaviour and Biometeorology 8:104–110.
  4. Beňo, F., T. Škorpilová, V. Pohůnek, J. Bauer, and R. Ševčík. 2021. Comparison of the automatic and manual broiler pre‐slaughter chain based on trailer microclimate during transportation and its effect on m. Pectoralis major. Animals 11.
  5. Bianchi, M., M. Petracci, and C. Cavani. 2005. Effects of transport and lairage on mortality, liveweight loss and carcass quality in broiler chickens. Ital J Anim Sci 4:516–518.
  6. Castellini, C., S. Mattioli, L. Piottoli, A. C. Mancinelli, D. Ranucci, R. Branciari, M. G. Amato, and A. Dal Bosco. 2016. Effect of transport length on in vivo oxidative status and breast meat characteristics in outdoor-reared chicken genotypes. Ital J Anim Sci 15:191–199.
  7. Dadgar, S., E. S. Lee, T. L. V. Leer, N. Burlinguette, H. L. Classen, T. G. Crowe, and P. J. Shand. 2010. Effect of microclimate temperature during transportation of broiler chickens on quality of the pectoralis major muscle. Poult Sci 89:1033–1041.
  8. Fu, Y., J. Yin, N. Zhao, G. Xue, R. Zhang, J. Li, and J. Bao. 2022. Effects of transport time and feeding type on weight loss, meat quality and behavior of broilers. Anim Biosci 35:1039–1047.
  9. Gou, Z., K. F. M. Abouelezz, Q. Fan, L. Li, X. Lin, Y. Wang, X. Cui, J. Ye, M. A. Masoud, S. Jiang, and X. Ma. 2021a. Physiological effects of transport duration on stress biomarkers and meat quality of medium-growing Yellow broiler chickens. Animal 15.
  10. Gou, Z., K. F. M. Abouelezz, Q. Fan, L. Li, X. Lin, Y. Wang, X. Cui, J. Ye, M. A. Masoud, S. Jiang, and X. Ma. 2021b. Physiological effects of transport duration on stress biomarkers and meat quality of medium-growing Yellow broiler chickens. Animal 15.
  11. He, T., J. Ma, S. Mahfuz, Y. Zheng, S. Long, J. Wang, D. Wu, and X. Piao. 2022. Dietary live yeast supplementation alleviates transport-stress-impaired meat quality of broilers through maintaining muscle energy metabolism and antioxidant status. J Sci Food Agric 102:4086–4096.
  12. Hussnain, F., A. Mahmud, S. Mehmood, and M. H. Jaspal. 2020. Effect of broiler crating density and transportation distance on preslaughter losses and physiological response during the winter season in Punjab, Pakistan. Rev Bras Cienc Avic 22:1–10.
  13. Ibrahim, H., and A. Aziz. 2021. Alleviating Transport Stress of Broiler Using Vitamin C and Acetyl Salicylic Acid. Journal of Animal and Poultry Production 12:169–173.
  14. Jacobs, L., E. Delezie, L. Duchateau, K. Goethals, B. Ampe, E. Lambrecht, X. Gellynck, and F. A. M. Tuyttens. 2016. Effect of post-hatch transportation duration and parental age on broiler chicken quality, welfare, and productivity. Poult Sci 95:1973–1979.
  15. Joanna Doktor, and Katarzyna Połtowicz. 2009. Doktor and Połtowicz, 2009. Ann. Anim. Sci 9:307–317.
  16. Lan, R., Q. Chang, and Y. Lu. 2021a. Effects of chitosan oligosaccharides on meat quality, muscle energy metabolism and anti-oxidant status in broilers that have experienced transport stress. Anim Prod Sci 61:1625–1632.
  17. Lan, R., Q. Chang, and Y. Lu. 2021b. Effects of chitosan oligosaccharides on meat quality, muscle energy metabolism and anti-oxidant status in broilers that have experienced transport stress. Anim Prod Sci 61:1625–1632.
  18. Lee, Y. H. 2019. Strengths and Limitations of Meta-Analysis. The Korean Journal of Medicine 94:391–395.
  19. Lee, Y. H., and G. G. Song. 2021. Comparative efficacy and safety of secukinumab and ixekizumab in patients with active ankylosing spondylitis. Z Rheumatol 80:776–784.
  20. Liu, J., D. Liu, X. Wu, C. Pan, S. Wang, and L. Ma. 2022. Tmt quantitative proteomics analysis reveals the effects of transport stress on iron metabolism in the liver of chicken. Animals 12.
  21. di Martino, G., K. Capello, E. Russo, M. Mazzucato, P. Mulatti, N. Ferrè, A. Garbo, M. Brichese, S. Marangon, and L. Bonfanti. 2017. Factors associated with pre-slaughter mortality in turkeys and end of lay hens. Animal 11:2295–2300.
  22. Ondrasovicova· O., Saba L., smirjakova S., Vargova· M., Ondrasovic M., Matta S., Lakticova· K., and Wnuk W. 2008. ONDRAŠOVIÈOVÁ, 2019. Medycyna Wet 64:292–293.
  23. Pan, L., X. K. Ma, P. F. Zhao, Q. H. Shang, S. F. Long, Y. Wu, and X. S. Piao. 2018. Forsythia suspensa extract attenuates breast muscle oxidative injury induced by transport stress in broilers. Poult Sci 97:1554–1563.
  24. Perai, A. H., H. Kermanshahi, H. N. Moghaddam, and A. Zarban. 2015. Effects of chromium and chromium + vitamin C combination on metabolic, oxidative, and fear responses of broilers transported under summer conditions. Int J Biometeorol 59:453–462.
  25. Petracci, M., M. Bianchi, C. Cavani, P. Gaspari, and A. Lavazza. 2006. Preslaughter Mortality in Broiler Chickens, Turkeys, and Spent Hens Under Commercial Slaughtering. Poultry Science 85:1660–1664.
  26. Ranjbar, K., A. Khatibjoo, F. Fatahnia, and F. Fattahnia. 2014. Effects of vitamin c, echium amoenum and lavender extract on blood metabolite and meat quality of broiler chickens under transport stress. Global Journal of Animal Scientific Research 2:159–169 Available at www.gjasr.com.
  27. R. O.de S., L., G. S. Simões, A. L. Soares, A. Oba, A. Rossa, M. Shimokomaki, and E. I. Ida. 2010. Broiler transportation conditions in a brazilian commercial line and the occurrence of breast PSE (Pale, Soft, Exudative) meat and DFD-like (Dark, Firm, Dry) meat. Arch. Biol. Technol. 53:1161–1167.
  28. Sara, U., M. Azhar, D. Rahardja, dan H. Sonjaya, J. Peternakan, and P. Pembangunan Pertanian Gowa. 2019. PENGARUH PENYIRAMAN SEBELUM PENGANGKUTAN DENGAN JARAK BERBEDA TERHADAP PERFORMA AYAM RAS PEDAGING EFFECT OF WATER SPRAYING BEFORE TRANSPORTATION OF DIFFERENT DISTANCES ON BROILER PERFORMANCES.
  29. Sarkar, P., S. Ghosh, S. Batabyal, and S. Chatterjee. 2013. Biochemical stress responses of broiler chickens during transport. Indian J. Anim. Res 47:29–34.
  30. Savenije, B., E. Lambooij, M. A. Gerritzen, K. Venema, and J. Korf. 2002. Effects of feed deprivation and transport on preslaughter blood metabolites, early postmortem muscle metabolites, and meat quality. Poult Sci 81:699–708.
  31. Schroeder, S. R. 2018. Do Bilinguals Have an Advantage in Theory of Mind? A Meta-Analysis. Front Commun (Lausanne) 3.
  32. Tamzil, M. H., B. Indarsih, I. N. S. Jaya, and N. K. D. Haryani. 2022. Stres pengangkutan pada ternak unggas, pengaruh dan upaya penanggulangan. Livestock and Animal Research 20:48.
  33. Taylor, N. L., D. L. Fletcher, J. K. Northcutt, and M. P. Lacy. 2001. Effect of transport cage height on broiler live shrink and defecation patterns. J. Appl. Poult. Res. 10:335–339.
  34. Vecerek, V., S. Grbalova, E. Voslarova, B. Janackova, and M. Malena. 2006. Effects of travel distance and the season of the year on death rates of broilers transported to poultry processing plants. Poult Sci 85:1881–1884.
  35. Vosmerova, P., J. Chloupek, I. Bedanova, P. Chloupek, K. Kruzikova, J. Blahova, and V. Vecerek. 2010. Changes in selected biochemical indices related to transport of broilers to slaughterhouse under different ambient temperatures. Poult Sci 89:2719–2725.
  36. Wang, X., J. Li, J. Cong, X. Chen, X. Zhu, L. Zhang, F. Gao, and G. Zhou. 2017. Preslaughter Transport Effect on Broiler Meat Quality and Post-mortem Glycolysis Metabolism of Muscles with Different Fiber Types. J Agric Food Chem 65:10310–10316.
  37. Widyasari, D. N., N. Ulupi, R. Afnan, R. Mutia, and J. A. Lase. 2021. Performance and Quality of Broiler Meat During Transportation with Various Durations and ZnSO4 level. Buletin Peternakan 45:170.
  38. Xing, T., M. F. Wang, M. Y. Han, X. S. Zhu, X. L. Xu, and G. H. Zhou. 2017. Expression of heat shock protein 70 in transport-stressed broiler pectoralis major muscle and its relationship with meat quality. Animal 11:1599–1607.
  39. Yalçin, S., and H. C. Güler. 2012. Interaction of transport distance and body weight on preslaughter stress and breast meat quality of broilers. Br Poult Sci 53:175–182.
  40. Zhang, C., Z. Y. Geng, K. K. Chen, X. H. Zhao, and C. Wang. 2019. L-theanine attenuates transport stress-induced impairment of meat quality of broilers through improving muscle antioxidant status. Poult Sci 98:4648–4655.
  41. Zhang, L., J. L. Li, T. Gao, M. Lin, X. F. Wang, X. D. Zhu, F. Gao, and G. H. Zhou. 2014. Effects of dietary supplementation with creatine monohydrate during the finishing period on growth performance, carcass traits, meat quality and muscle glycolytic potential of broilers subjected to transport stress. Animal 8:1955–1962.
  42. Zhang, B., N. Liu, Z. He, P. Song, M. Hao, Y. Xie, J. Li, R. Liu, and Z. Sun. 2021a. Guanidino-Acetic Acid: A Scarce Substance in Biomass That Can Regulate Postmortem Meat Glycolysis of Broilers Subjected to Pre-slaughter Transportation. Front Bioeng Biotechnol 8.
  43. Zhang, B., N. Liu, Z. He, P. Song, M. Hao, Y. Xie, J. Li, R. Liu, and Z. Sun. 2021b. Guanidino-Acetic Acid: A Scarce Substance in Biomass That Can Regulate Postmortem Meat Glycolysis of Broilers Subjected to Pre-slaughter Transportation. Front Bioeng Biotechnol 8.
  44. Zhang, B., N. Liu, K. Kang, R. Zhang, M. Hao, P. Song, Q. Wang, Y. Xie, and C. Li. 2022. Dietary guanidineacetic acid supplementation ameliorated meat quality and regulated muscle metabolism of broilers subjected to pre-slaughter transport stress by metabolomics analysis. Poult Sci 101.
  45. Zhang, C., L. Wang, X. H. Zhao, X. Y. Chen, L. Yang, and Z. Y. Geng. 2017. Dietary resveratrol supplementation prevents transport-stress-impaired meat quality of broilers through maintaining muscle energy metabolism and antioxidant status. Poult Sci 96:2219–2225.
  46. Zhang, L., H. Y. Yue, H. J. Zhang, L. Xu, S. G. Wu, H. J. Yan, Y. S. Gong, and G. H. Qi. 2009a. Transport stress in broilers: I. Blood metabolism, glycolytic potential, and meat quality. Poult Sci 88:2033–2041.
  47. Zhang, L., H. Y. Yue, H. J. Zhang, L. Xu, S. G. Wu, H. J. Yan, Y. S. Gong, and G. H. Qi. 2009b. Transport stress in broilers: I. Blood metabolism, glycolytic potential, and meat quality. Poult Sci 88:2033–2041.
  48. Zheng, A., S. Lin, S. A. Pirzado, Z. Chen, W. Chang, H. Cai, and G. Liu. 2020. Stress associated with simulated transport, changes serum biochemistry, postmortem muscle metabolism, and meat quality of broilers. Animals 10:1–12.